My Female Boss Knocked on My Door at Midnight and Said I Can’t Stop Thinking About You…
Look, I’m not the kind of guy who gets himself into messy situations. I’m careful. I plan things out. I keep my personal life and work life in completely separate boxes. But right now, at 3:00 in the morning, sitting on my couch with a whiskey I haven’t touched. I’m realizing that sometimes life doesn’t care about your boxes.
My name is Carter Hayes and I need to tell you what happened tonight before I lose my mind. I work at a marketing firm in Denver. Started there about 10 months ago as a senior strategist. The pay was good. The work was interesting. And my boss was someone I never expected to complicate my entire existence. Her name is Sloan Mercer, 31, 3 years older than me.
She had this dark red hair that she always wore pulled back tight like she was trying to control it. A green eyes that could cut through your excuses in half a second. She wore these perfectly tailored blazers and heels that clicked against the office floor like a countdown. Everything about her screamed controlled, competent, untouchable, and I was so stupidly attracted to her.
It made me feel like a teenager. For the first 6 months, I handled it. I was professional. I focused on my work. I didn’t let myself think about the curve of her neck when she leaned over my desk or the way she’d bite her lower lip when she was concentrating. I definitely didn’t think about what it would feel like to make her lose some of that control.
Except I did think about it all the time. The thing is, I was pretty sure it wasn’t just me. There were these moments where I’d catch her watching me during meetings. Or she’d laugh at something I said, and it would sound different than her professional laugh, softer, real. Sometimes when we’d work late, just the two of us.
The air would get thick with something neither of us would acknowledge, but we didn’t cross any lines. We were adults. We had boundaries until we didn’t. It started 4 weeks ago on a Wednesday night. We were finalizing a presentation for a huge client meeting the next morning. Everyone else had left hours earlier. The cleaning crew had already come and gone.
It was just us in her office running on coffee and adrenaline. I was standing at her desk, leaning over to point at something on her laptop screen. She turned her head to say something and suddenly her face was right there. So close I could see the tiny gold flexcks in her eyes. Could smell whatever perfume she wore. That’s something that reminded me of vanilla and smoke. We both froze.
Her lips parted slightly. My hand was braced on her desk and my knuckles had gone white from gripping the edge. The moment stretched out so long I forgot how to breathe. “Carter,” she said my name quietly, almost like a question. I should have stepped back. Should have laughed it off or made some joke to break the tension.
Instead, I stayed exactly where I was, watching her watch me. We should finish this, she finally said, but her voice had gone rough around the edges. Yeah. I stepped back, shoved my hands in my pockets. Yeah, definitely. We finished the presentation. We didn’t talk about what had almost happened. But after that night, something shifted between us. The glances got longer.
The late nights got more frequent. We’d find excuses to work together, yet to stay in the office when everyone else left. It was like we were both seeing how close we could get to the fire without actually touching it. Last Monday, she asked me to grab drinks after work to celebrate landing a new account. just the two of us.
We went to this quiet bar downtown, sat in a corner booth, and talked for three hours about everything except work. She told me about her divorce 2 years ago, about how she threw herself into her career because it was easier than dealing with the loneliness. I told her about moving to Denver to get away from my ex, about feeling stuck between who I used to be and who I wanted to become.
At one point, her hand was resting on the table and mine was next to it. Our pinkies almost touching. The space between our fingers felt electric. “I should get going,” she said eventually. “Oh, but she didn’t move.” “Probably a good idea,” I agreed. Also, not moving. We sat there for another 10 minutes before she finally stood up.
I walked her to her car. We said good night. I watched her drive away and knew I was in serious trouble. Which brings me to tonight. I’d gone home around 7, ordered pizza, tried to watch a game, but couldn’t focus. Took a shower, got into bed around 11:30, and just stared at the ceiling, thinking about her like I always did.
At midnight, my phone buzzed. A text from Sloan. Are you awake? My heart kicked into overdrive. She’d never texted me this late. Never texted me anything personal at all. Really, just work stuff. I typed back, “Yeah, everything okay?” Those three dots appeared, disappeared, appeared again. “Can I call you?” I sat up in bed, suddenly wide awake. “Sure.
” My phone rang 5 seconds later. Hey, I answered, trying to sound casual, even though my pulse was racing. Hey. Her voice sounded different, shakier than usual. I’m sorry to bother you so late. You’re not bothering me. What’s going on? A pause. I could hear her breathing on the other end. I’m outside your building. Everything stopped.
What? I know this is crazy. I know I shouldn’t be here, but I’ve been sitting in my car for 20 minutes trying to talk myself into leaving, and I can’t.” She let out a shaky laugh. I can’t stop thinking about you, Carter. And I know this is wrong and complicated and probably the stupidest thing I could possibly do.
But I had to see you. I had to. What’s your apartment number? I told her. Hung up. stood there in my boxers and t-shirt, heart absolutely pounding, but trying to process what was happening. Sloan was here at my apartment at midnight. I threw on jeans, ran my hands through my hair, checked my breath.
My hands were actually shaking. I felt like I was 17 again, nervous and reckless, and completely out of my depth. The knock came 3 minutes later. I opened the door. She was standing there in jeans and a sweater, hair down for once, falling in waves past her shoulders. No makeup. She looked younger, vulnerable, beautiful in a way that made my chest ache. “Hi,
” she said softly. “Hi.” We stood there staring at each other. Every rational thought in my head was screaming at me to be careful, to think this through, to remember that she was my boss and this could destroy both our careers. Then she stepped forward, reached up, and touched my face. Her hand was cold against my cheek. “Uh, tell me to leave,” she whispered.
“Tell me this is a mistake and I’ll go and we’ll pretend this never happened.” I should have. I really should have. Instead, I covered her hand with mine and said, “I don’t want you to leave.” She closed her eyes like I’d just confirmed something she’d been afraid to hope for. When she opened them again, they were darker, determined.
“I want you tonight, Carter.” Her voice was barely above a whisper, but it hit me like a shout. I’ve wanted you for months and I’m tired of pretending I don’t. Before I could respond, she kissed me and everything changed. The second her lips touched mine, every careful thought I’d ever had disappeared. She kissed me like she’d been starving for it, like all those months of tension and wanting had finally snapped.
My hands found her waist and pulled her inside a kicking the door shut behind us. Her fingers tangled in my hair and she made this small sound against my mouth that nearly killed me. We stumbled backward into my apartment. I barely registered where we were going. All I knew was the taste of her.
The feel of her body pressed against mine. The way she was breathing my name between kisses like it was the only word she remembered. My back hit the wall. She pressed against me, her hands sliding under my shirt, fingers cold against my skin. I groaned, and she pulled back just enough to look at me, her eyes wild and bright.
“Is this okay?” she asked, breathless. I answered by lifting her up, her legs wrapped around my waist, and I carried her to the couch, setting her down and following her back against the cushions. We were a tangle of limbs and desperate touches, trying to get closer, trying to make up for all the times we’d stopped ourselves. But then something shifted.
She broke the kiss suddenly, her hand flat against my chest. I pulled back immediately, searching her face. “Wait,” she whispered. “Carter, wait.” I moved off her, sitting back, trying to catch my breath. “What’s wrong?” She sat up, running, shaking hands through her hair. I can’t do this.
The words hit me like cold water. Okay, that’s okay. We can stop. No, I mean, she stood up, pacing across my small living room. I can’t do this to you. This isn’t fair. I stayed on the couch, watching her, confused and still reeling. What are you talking about? She turned to face me, and I saw tears in her eyes. real tears.
Sloan Mercer, who never showed emotion at work, who was always in control, was crying in my living room. “I got a job offer,” she said quietly. “In Seattle, regional director position. It’s everything I’ve been working toward. Triple the salary, real authority, a chance to actually build something.” My stomach dropped. when they called me this afternoon.
They want an answer by Monday. She wrapped her arms around herself. I was going to take it. I’d already decided. It’s the smart move, the career move. Yeah. But then tonight, I was sitting alone in my apartment thinking about leaving and all I could think about was you. I stood up, walked over to her.
Sloan, I came here to tell you, she continued, the words spilling out now. I came here to tell you about the job and to finally admit how I feel about you, even though it’s insane and inappropriate and probably career suicide. But then I got here and you looked at me like that and I thought maybe we could just have tonight.
One night where I don’t think about consequences or what’s smart. just one night where I get to have what I want.” She wiped her eyes roughly, smearing mascara across her cheek. “But I can’t do that to you. I can’t sleep with you, knowing I’m leaving. That’s not fair. That’s not who I want to be.” I reached out and gently wiped the mascara from her face with my thumb, and she closed her eyes at the touch.
“What do you want?” I asked quietly. Forget the job. Forget what’s smart. What do you actually want? She opened her eyes and looked at me with so much raw honesty, it hurt you. I want you, but I also want that job. I’ve worked for 15 years to get an opportunity like this. How do I choose? Maybe you don’t have to. She laughed, but it came out broken.
Seattle’s a thousand miles away, Carter. Long distance doesn’t work. Especially not when we’ve never even been together. We’d be building a relationship on nothing but phone calls and hope. Or you could turn it down. I can’t ask you to be the reason I give up this opportunity. What if we try this and it doesn’t work out? Then I’ll have given up everything for nothing.
I knew she was right. The logical part of my brain knew every word she was saying made sense. But the rest of me didn’t care about logic. Stay, I said. Stay in Denver. We’ll figure this out together. Carter, I’m serious. You want to know what I want? I want to take you to dinner. Real dinner. Not late night work sessions disguised as meals. I want to wake up next to you.
I want to see what this could actually be without hiding it or pretending it’s not happening. I took her hands in mine. You’re terrified this won’t work out. But what if it does? What if this is the thing you’ve been missing while you were busy building your career? She was crying again silently this time.
You’re asking me to gamble my entire future on a relationship that doesn’t even exist yet. No, I’m asking you to give us a chance. Take the weekend. Think about it. But don’t make this decision alone in your head at midnight when you’re scared. I squeezed her hands. And for what it’s worth, I think you’re worth the risk.
Whatever happens, I think you’re worth it. She stared at me for a long moment. Then she pulled her hands free and stepped back. I should go. Sloan, please. I need to think. I need to not be here with you looking at me like that because I can’t think straight when you do. I wanted to argue, wanted to kiss her again and make her forget about Seattle and jobs and every logical reason why this was complicated.
But I didn’t because she was right. This decision was too big to make like this. Okay, I said go think. But Sloan, whatever you decide, I meant what I said. You’re worth it. She nodded, not trusting herself to speak. And then she grabbed her purse and headed for the door. She paused with her hand on the knob, looking back at me one more time.
“I’ve never felt like this about anyone,” she whispered. “That’s what scares me most.” “Then she was gone. I stood there in my living room, heart still racing, lips still tingling from her kiss, and realized that my entire future was now in the hands of a woman who’ just walked out my door. All I could do was wait. Part three. I didn’t sleep that night.
Not even close. I sat on my couch until the sun came up, replaying everything over and over. the way she’d kissed me, the tears in her eyes, the sound of my door closing behind her. By the time Saturday morning light started filtering through my blinds, I’d convinced myself I’d never hear from her again.
She’d take the job. Of course, she would. It was the smart choice, not the safe choice. And Sloan Mercer always made the smart choice. I finally dragged myself to the shower around 8, then to the kitchen to make coffee. I didn’t want. My phone sat on the counter, silent, mocking me. The weekend crawled by like torture.
I tried to distract myself, went to the gym, cleaned my apartment, called my sister, and pretended everything was fine. The whole time, my phone stayed quiet. By Sunday night, I’d accepted it. She was taking the Seattle job. She was choosing her career. I couldn’t blame her for that, even if it felt like my chest had been carved out with a spoon.
I went to bed early, dreading Monday morning, dreading having to see her at work and pretend nothing had happened. Pretend I hadn’t kissed her and told her she was worth risking everything for Monday morning. I dragged myself into the office at 8:30. My stomach was in knots. I grabbed coffee from the break room and headed to my desk.
eyes down, just trying to get through the day. Carter. I looked up. Sloan was standing outside her office, wearing that charcoal blazer I’d always liked. Hair pulled back every inch the professional boss she’d always been. My heart sank. Can I see you in my office, please? Her voice was formal, distant. This was it.
She was going to tell me she was leaving and we were going to have an awkward conversation about maintaining professionalism and then I’d have to watch her pack up her desk. I followed her inside. She closed the door behind us and turned to face me. For a moment, we just looked at each other. “I turned down the job,” she said quietly.
I blinked. “What?” I called them Saturday afternoon and turned it down. She crossed her arms, but it looked more like she was holding herself together than anything else. I’ve been thinking about what you said, about what I want. And you were right. I’ve spent 15 years building a career and climbing ladders and checking boxes.
I’ve been so focused on the next promotion, the next achievement, that I forgot to actually build a life. She took a breath, her eyes meeting mine. I don’t want to wake up in 5 years as a regional director in Seattle, sitting alone in some fancy apartment, wondering what would have happened if I’d been brave enough to choose something just because it made me happy.
I don’t want to regret you, Carter. My heart was pounding so hard I could barely hear anything else. Are you sure? That job was everything you wanted. No, she said firmly. It was everything I thought I should want. There’s a difference. She stepped closer. But here’s the thing. I’m not doing this halfway. If we’re going to try this, we do it right.
No hiding. No sneaking around. Which means I went to HR this morning and submitted my resignation. You what? I’m giving 4 weeks notice. I’ll help transition my projects and find my replacement, but then I’m leaving the company. She smiled. Uh, and it was the first real smile I’d seen from her in days.
I already have three interviews lined up at other firms. Turns out my reputation is pretty solid in Denver. I’ll find something else. But I can’t be your boss and your girlfriend. That’s not fair to you or to anyone else on the team. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. Sloan, you don’t have to quit. We can figure something out.
I want to, she interrupted. I want to start fresh, build something new, and I want to do it with you if you still want that. I closed the distance between us in two steps, cupping her face in my hands. Are you kidding me? I haven’t stopped thinking about you for 2 seconds since Friday night. She laughed and it sounded lighter than I’d ever heard it.
So, we’re really doing this? We’re making the impulsive uh probably crazy decision. Yeah, I said grinning. We really are. HR said we need to keep things professional for the next 4 weeks while I’m still technically employed here. That’s going to be torture. I know. She bit her lip, eyes dancing, but after that, you’re taking me to dinner.
Real dinner. And then I want you to kiss me the way you did Friday night and not stop. I can definitely make that happen. She reached up and straightened my collar, fingers lingering against my neck. I’m terrified, you know. I don’t know what I’m doing. I’ve never taken a risk like this. Me neither, I admitted.
But I think that’s kind of the point. We figure it out together. Together, she repeated like she was testing out the word. Then she smiled. I like the sound of that. Someone knocked on the door and we stepped apart quickly. Sloan cleared her throat and called out, “Come in.” It was Sarah from accounting with a question about budget reports.
Professional Sloan snapped back into place instantly, handling the question with her usual efficiency. But as Sarah left and closed the door behind her, Sloan glanced at me and winked. 4 weeks suddenly felt like an eternity, but I could wait for her. I could wait. That night, she texted me, “23 days until I’m officially unemployed, and we can do this for real.
But who’s counting?” I texted back, “Me? I’m definitely counting.” 3 months later, Sloan started as marketing director at a competitor firm with better hours and better pay. We’d been officially dating for 2 months and she’d already met my family. Yeah, I’d never been happier in my life. 6 months after that, she moved into my apartment because she was spending every night there anyway. A year later, I proposed.
She said yes before I even finished asking. People thought we were crazy, moving too fast, taking too many risks. Maybe we were. But sometimes the best things in life are the ones you don’t plan for. The ones that scare you into being brave. Sloan taught me that. The night she showed up at midnight and whispered she wanted me, she changed everything.
And I’d make that same choice every single time. Some risks are just worth taking.
