My HOA President Declared War On 14 Ducks — The Ducks Won

 

HOA president called the police on me for fishing on my own dock on my own lake. The cops showed up, read the rule book, shrugged, and told her to stop wasting his time. That was strike two. By strike five, she had sent two men with shotguns to my property. And that is when I stopped being patient.

 

 

 But let me back up because you need to understand who this woman was before you can understand what I did. And you need to understand what I did before you can understand why nobody in this neighborhood has asked me a single question about it in 9 months. 

 

 And membership is just 13 cents a day. You have spent more than that on a piece of gum. So, do yourself a favor and hit that join button right below. You will not regret it.

 

 72% of that lake is on my property. Not my opinion. Not a number I pulled from thin air. It is the exact figure printed on the official county survey signed, stamped, and filed with the county recorder’s office before I ever put one box inside that house. The HOA president looked me dead in the eyes in broad daylight on a Tuesday afternoon and told me I was not allowed to use it.

 

That is where this story starts. I’m going to tell you right now, it does not end where you think it is going to end. I bought that house 3 years ago. The lake was part of the reason. My realtor walked me down to the dock the first day I saw the property and said, “Look, 72% of this water is yours.

 

” That number stuck with me because it was specific. Not half, not most. 72. I signed the paperwork. I moved in. For the first eight months, nothing happened. I walked the edge in the mornings. I sat on the dock. Some evenings, I watched the sun go down over the water. Nobody said a word to me.

 

 No phone calls, no notes on the door, no neighbors waving me down in the street. Everything was quiet. Then I decided to go fishing. I drove to the hardware store, bought a rod and a basic tackle kit, came home and walked down to my dock. I set up my chair. I opened a thermos of coffee. I put my line in the water. I sat there for maybe 10 minutes.

 

Just 10 minutes. The water was still. The birds were doing their thing. It was genuinely one of the most peaceful 10 minutes I had experienced in a long time. Then I heard her. I did not know who she was yet. I just heard a voice coming from the far end of the bank, getting louder and louder as it got closer.

 

 And the word I kept picking out of the noise was unacceptable. That word specifically, unacceptable. Over and over. Then she came around the bend and I saw her for the first time. Karen, HOA president. She was walking fast, both arms swinging, pointing at me from about 40 yards away before she had even finished closing the distance.

 

 She got to the edge of the dock and she said loudly, clearly, looking directly at me, “Fishing in this lake is permanently banned. You need to pack up and leave right now.” >> “You cannot fish here. Fishing is banned.” >> I looked at her for a second. I said, “I own 72% of this lake.” She said, “That doesn’t matter. it is a community asset.

 

I said, “I have a county survey that says otherwise.” She said, “I don’t care what your survey says. This is an HOA community and what I say about this lake is final.” Then she told me if I did not leave, she would escalate. I asked what escalate meant. She did not answer that. She just stared at me until I packed up my chair and my thermos and walked back to my house.

 

 Here’s where I made what I thought at the time was my first mistake. I went inside. I sat down at my kitchen table. I thought to myself, “Okay, before I do anything else, I am going to read the rule book.” All of it. Because maybe I missed something. Maybe there was a fishing restriction buried somewhere in the fine print and I just had not come across it.

 

 I was willing to accept that. So, I opened the HOA welcome packet that was still sitting in my filing cabinet from when I moved in and I pulled out the rule book, 187 pages. I made a fresh pot of coffee. I sat back down. I read every single page. I finished it around midnight. There was no rule against fishing. Not one sentence, not one clause, not even a vague gray area paragraph that could be stretched in that direction if you really wanted to. Nothing.

 

 No mention of fishing at all. Not in the lake section, not in the amenities section, not in the nuisance section, not in the general conduct section, nowhere. She had made it up. She had walked up to my dock, looked me in the face, and told me fishing was permanently banned when there was not one word in 187 pages of official HOA rules that supported that.

I sat with that for a minute. Then I put the rule book in my jacket pocket. I decided I was going back to that dock next Saturday. The week went by. I did not hear from her. No note, no email, no knock on the door. Maybe she thought that was the end of it. Maybe she figured I had gone home, accepted what she said, and moved on.

 I don’t know what she thought. What I know is that Saturday came and I loaded up my chair and my rod and a fresh thermos, and I walked back down to the dock and put my line in the water. She made it 9 minutes this time. 9 minutes before I heard that voice again, coming around the bend, arms already swinging.

 She got to the edge of the dock and she said, “I told you. I told you fishing was banned. I told you what would happen.” I said, “I read the rule book, all of it, cover to cover. There is no rule against fishing.” She said, “I don’t need a rule. I am the president of this HOA and I have the authority to prohibit activities that are detrimental to the community.

” I said, “Can you show me where that authority is in the rule book?” She said, “I don’t need to show you anything.” I said, “I’m going to keep fishing.” She took out her phone, but wait, it gets worse. She called the police, not animal control, not a property lawyer, not another HOA board member. She called the actual police to report a man sitting on his own dock fishing.

 And she stood right there on the bank and waited for them to arrive like she had just reported a kidnapping. The officer showed up about 20 minutes later. He was a young guy, maybe 30. He walked down to the dock, looked at my setup, looked at Karen, looked at the water, and then he said, “Okay, what’s the issue here?” Karen launched into it.

She told him fishing was banned. She told him I had been warned. She told him I was in violation of HOA rules. The officer asked if she had the rule book. She pulled it out of her bag. She handed it to him. He stood there and he flipped through it for about 3 minutes. Then he closed it. He handed it back to her.

 He looked at her. He said, “Ma’am, there is nothing in here about fishing.” She said, “Well, it should be there.” He said, “But it is not.” She said, “I have authority as president to prohibit activities.” He said, “That’s a civil matter, not a criminal one.” Then he looked at me, nodded once, and walked back up the bank.

 As he passed Karen, he said, “Please stop calling us about this.” He was gone. I kept fishing. Karen stood on the bank for another 4 minutes. She did not say anything. She just stood there. Then she left. I thought, “Okay, that should be the end of it.” The cop came, the cop looked at the rule book, the cop left. It is over. She made her play and it did not work.

We are done here. Nobody told me this part. Monday morning, I walked out to the dock and there was a sign nailed directly into one of the posts about 2 feet wide, no fishing, and black capital letters big enough to read from across the yard. She had walked onto my property while I was inside and nailed a sign to my dock.

 I stood there and I looked at it. I was not angry exactly. I was more just genuinely trying to understand what kind of person does this. This woman got in her car on a weekday, drove to a hardware store, bought a plastic sign, drove back, walked onto my property, and nailed it to my dock without knocking, without calling, without one single word to me.

That is a very deliberate choice. That is not impulsive. That is planned. I went inside and got a hammer and pulled the sign down. And that night, I burned it in the fire pit. That felt satisfying. I will not pretend it did not. But here’s what I did not understand yet. Removing the sign is not a message to Karen.

 Taking it down does not communicate that the sign is not welcome. What taking the sign down tells Karen is that one sign was insufficient. She came back Tuesday with two. I took both of them down. Thursday, there were three on the dock posts. I took all three. Over the next 11 days, she escalated steadily. Signs on the dock. Signs zip tied to my fence.

 A sign on the post at the end of my driveway. One morning, I found one cable tied to the lower rail of my gate. I removed every single one of them without ever calling her, emailing her, or acknowledging the situation out loud to anyone except my neighbor Dave, who could see my fire pit from his yard, and asked what I was burning so much of. I told him signs.

 He said, “How many signs?” I said, “Going on nine.” He said, “Good Lord.” And she was winning in a weird way. And I think she knew it because every sign cost her $8. and cost me 20 minutes of my afternoon. She could outlast me on that math. She had more time and more plastic signs than I had patience.

 And then the ducks showed up and the whole situation changed entirely. I want to be clear about something. I did not do anything to bring those ducks to that lake. I need you to understand that. I did not put feet out. I did not attract them. I did not plan this. One Tuesday morning, I walked out with my coffee, and there were 14 malards on my dock like they had always been there.

 Some sitting on the planks, some floating right up against the dock edge. They looked completely settled, and they liked me from the first day. I have no good explanation for it. I was not giving them food. I was not doing anything in particular toward them. But every time I walked out to the dock, they would all swim over and cluster around my chair.

 They would sit on the planks right next to my feet. And if I walked along the bank, they would get out of the water and fall in behind me. All 14 in a loose trail just following like I was their assigned person. And they had decided this was the arrangement. Now my neighbor Dave saw it happen one morning from his side of the fence.

 And he laughed for a solid four minutes. He watched them trail behind me down the bank and he said, “You look like the lead duck.” I told him I genuinely did not know why they did it. He said, “One of those birds is going to follow you into your living room eventually.” He was not far wrong. One morning, I walked up my back steps and turned around and a malard was right there on the second step, looking at me through the screen door.

 I liked having them there. There was something about sitting on the dock in the morning with 14 ducks just existing quietly around you that made it a different and better kind of morning. calmer, like the lake was full instead of empty. Karen noticed them on a Friday. I know it was a Friday because she knocked on my door that afternoon.

 No warning, no email, just a knock. And then she started talking before I had fully opened the door. She said the ducks were a health hazard. She said their droppings were accumulating on the community walking path. She said they were causing a sanitation issue. She said they were disrupting the visual standards of the neighborhood.

 She said they were attracting insects. She got very specific about the insects. She had a whole theory about the insects. And then she said I needed to remove all of them immediately. I said they are wild ducks. I did not bring them here. I cannot make them leave. She said you are clearly feeding them.

 I said I am not feeding them. She said then why do they follow you everywhere? I said I genuinely have no idea. I think they just like me. That answer did not land well. She stared at me for a moment like she was trying to figure out if I was being difficult on purpose or if I was actually this strange. And then she said the two words I should have taken far more seriously than I did.

 She said, “I will take action.” And she left. I heard take action and I thought the same things I had been thinking since October. Another sign. An angry email. Maybe she calls a community meeting and reads a prepared statement about ducks. Those were the moves I had seen. Those were what I expected. I was not thinking big enough.

 Four days later, I was on my porch. Coffee on the table. All 14 ducks were out on the lake doing nothing much. Some sleeping. Some drifting in slow circles. Quiet morning. Good morning. The kind where you were not really thinking about anything at all. And then Karen’s car pulled into the lot. I set my mug down and I watched her get out.

And she was carrying a broom, not a small one, a full-size floor broom with a wide bristle head, the kind you sweep a kitchen with. And she was walking with an energy I had not seen from her before. Not the hands-on hips confrontation energy, not the letter of the law lecturing energy. This was something new.

 This was I have made a decision and I am fully committed to it energy. I did not stand up. I just watched. She walked down the bank and out onto my dock. She stopped. She looked at the ducks. Some of them looked back at her. And then she started screaming. Both arms up, brooms swinging in wide overhead arcs, maximum volume, maximum movement.

 She was going to chase all 14 malards off the dock by sheer force of noise and aggression. And she had clearly decided she was completely capable of this. Now, I want you to picture what you think happens next. Because everybody I’ve ever told this story to pictures the same outcome. The ducks get scared and fly off. That is the logical result.

 Large threatening thing comes at you screaming. You leave. Basic response. The ducks scatter. Karen feels like she accomplished something. Life moves on. That is not what malards do. Malards do not flee when something they believe is threatening their home comes at them. When something comes at a group of malards the way Karen came at those 14 ducks, they do not run.

 They respond. All 14 of them came off that dock directly at her, not away from her, straight at her, wings fully out, beaks forward. Every single one making a sound that I do not have a good word for, except extremely committed and extremely loud. Karen turned and ran, and the ducks chased her off the dock and down the bank and along the waterline.

 She was running at full speed. They were keeping pace. She was screaming. They were screaming. She covered 100 ft of bank with every single one of those birds right behind her, wings beating, fully locked in, not dropping back at all. I have genuinely never in my life seen ducks run that fast. And I did not know they could.

 She had both arms pumping and she was going as hard as she could go and they matched her every step. And and then her foot caught the soft edge of the bank where the grass meets the water. She went down face first, both arms out, full body, straight into the shallows at the edge of the lake. No stumble, no catch, just completely horizontal, a full and total fall.

 The ducks stopped right at the bank. They stood there for a moment. And then, as a group, they turned around and walked back to the dock and resumed whatever they had been doing before as though absolutely nothing had happened. I did not stand up. I did not call out. I did not laugh. I picked my coffee up and I sat there on my porch and I watched. Karen got up slowly.

 She was soaked from her chest down, hair completely flat against her face. She straightened up and she looked around like she was checking who had seen. She looked at the ducks, settled back on the dock. She looked at the lake and then she looked directly at my porch. I raised my coffee cup. She did not say anything.

 She walked back to her car, got in, and she drove away. And she did not come back for 4 days. I want to tell you that was the end of it. I really do. I want to tell you Karen went home, dried off, thought about what had happened, and decided the lake and the ducks and the whole situation were not worth any more of her time.

 That would be a satisfying place to end this story. Woman chases ducks, ducks win, everyone goes home very clean. But that is not what happened because on day four, I was back on that same porch with the same coffee and the same 14 ducks sitting out on the lake, completely unbothered. and a truck I had never seen in this neighborhood before pulled up slow to the end of my driveway and stopped.

 Two men got out. Both of them dressed head to toe in camo, hunting vests, orange safety patches, lace up boots, and both of them were holding shotguns. They walked to my fence. The taller one looked down at the dock. He looked at the ducks. He looked at me and he said, “Hoa president gave us permission to callull the pest ducks.

” I looked at the guns. [snorts] I looked at the 14 birds sitting on my dock who did not know a single thing about what was currently happening at my fence line. I set my coffee down very slowly and I stood up because in that moment I had about 3 seconds to decide exactly what I was going to say. And what came out of my mouth next was either going to end with 14 dead ducks or end with something Karen was absolutely not prepared for.

 I walked to the fence. I looked at both of them and I said it. Those are not wild ducks. That is what I said. I leaned on that fence post and I looked at both of them and I said it flat and calm like I was reading the weather. Those are not wild ducks. Those are my pets. Every single one of them.

 And if you shoot one of them, I will have you arrested for felony destruction of property. The taller one with the shotgun looked at me. He looked at the dock. He looked back at me. and his entire face went through about four different expressions in about two seconds. Confusion first, then doubt, then something that looked a lot like the specific panic of a man who just realized the job he agreed to do might have some significant legal complications attached to it.

 He said, “Wait, what?” I said, “Nothing.” He said, “She told us they were feral. She said they were rats with wings, a health hazard. She said she had full authority to authorize removal. I looked at him. I said, “That is between you and her. I am just telling you what happens if you shoot one of my animals on my property.

” The second guy had not said anything yet. He was still looking at the ducks. And the ducks, because they are who they are, had started to drift over to my side of the lake slowly, casually, like they were coming over to watch. 14 malards moving as one quiet group toward the fence where two men with shotguns were standing.

 It was, I will admit, an extremely good piece of accidental timing. The taller one looked at them coming. He lowered his gun slightly. And he said to his partner, “I’m not doing this.” His partner said, “Same.” And they both looked at me and the taller one said, “We are very sorry for the trouble.” He said it like he meant it. He picked up his bag.

 They walked back to the truck. The engine started. They pulled away. I stood at the fence for another minute. I looked at the ducks. The ducks looked at me and then they turned around and went back to the dock like they had made their point and were done. I went inside and made more coffee. Now, I want to tell you I planned all of that.

 I want to sit here and tell you I had been three moves ahead the entire time that I knew Karen was going to hire someone that I had my response ready and waiting. That would make for a much better story. The truth is I had about 1 and a half seconds at that fence and one thought in my head and that thought was whatever I say right now needs to make those two men get back in that truck.

 I said the thing that came to me and it worked and I am not going to claim it was genius. But I am also not going to pretend it did not feel like the most satisfying 11 seconds I had experienced in about 4 months. But wait, it gets worse. Not for me, for Karen. Because about an hour after the truck left, I got a notification on my phone.

 I have a Google alert set up for my neighborhood name. I set it up years ago to catch any local news about the area. It almost never produces anything useful. Property sales occasionally. A lost dog post once in a while, not much. This notification was different. Someone had left a one-star review on a real estate agent’s business page.

 The agent’s name was Karen. And the review said, and I’m not summarizing here, the review said exactly this. Called us out to remove ducks she claimed were feral pests. Ducks turned out to be registered pets. She had no authority to authorize removal and provided false information. One star. Do not recommend.

 We will not work with this person again. It was posted under a name I did not recognize, but the profile picture was a man in a camo vest. I read it twice. I set my phone face down on the counter and I did not touch it again for the rest of the afternoon because I needed a few hours to just sit with the fact that this was real life and not something I had written.

 Karen’s real estate page where her clients go, where people looking to buy or sell a home in this area go to decide if she is someone they want to trust with the largest purchase of their lives. That review was going to be the first thing anybody saw when they searched her name and it was going to sit there. One star. False information. Do not recommend from a man in a camouflage vest she hired to shoot 14 ducks that were not what she said they were.

 I genuinely did not know what was coming next. And that should have been a warning because the times in this story when I thought I had some idea of what Karen’s next move would be were consistently the times she surprised me. and she was about to surprise me again. 3 days later, a letter showed up in my mailbox.

 Official HOA letterhead, black ink. It said there would be an emergency community meeting the following Tuesday at the community center. Agenda item one, immediate removal of nuisance water foul from HOA common areas. Mandatory attendance requested. Mandatory attendance requested. Not required. Requested. That word was doing a lot of work.

 I folded the letter and put it back in the envelope and set it on the kitchen counter and I thought about whether I wanted to go. Here is what I knew going in. Karen needed a vote. The HOA rule book is clear on one thing above almost everything else and that is that the president cannot spend HOA money without community approval. She wanted to hire pest control.

 Pest control for 14 ducks was quoted in the letter at $1,800. to spend $1,800 of community money. She needed a majority vote in her favor. That was the game. She was going to stand in front of all 32 homeowners in this neighborhood and make the case that the ducks were dangerous and unacceptable and needed to go and that it was worth nearly $2,000 to make that happen. I went on Tuesday.

 The community center holds about 60 people if everyone brings their own chair from home. On a normal evening, maybe 15 people show up to HOA meetings. Not everyone, not even most people. People who care about a specific issue come and everyone else watches whatever is on television. That is just how it works.

 I expected the usual numbers, maybe a few more because of the emergency notice. There were 31 people in that room when I walked in. That is basically every household. That is a number I have never seen at one of these meetings. People had brought their own chairs from home and lined them up in extra rows.

 A husband and wife I had never spoken to in 3 years of living here nodded at me when I came in. Dave was already there, second row, arms crossed, looking very awake for a Tuesday evening. A woman I knew from the mailbox cluster, Margaret, waved at me from across the room. She is in her late 60s and has lived here since the neighborhood was built.

 She is the kind of person who sees everything and says almost nothing until she decides to say something and then she says exactly what needs to be said. I took a seat near the middle. Karen was at the front. She had a foldout table with papers on it and a small whiteboard on a stand behind her. She had prepared visual aids.

 She had printed photographs. I could see from where I was sitting that some of them were pictures of duck droppings on a sidewalk. She had printed and laminated photographs of duck droppings. I want you to sit with that for a moment. She had gone to the effort of photographing, printing, and laminating the evidence.

This was not someone improvising. This was someone who had spent a significant portion of the previous week preparing this presentation. The meeting was supposed to start at 7. At 6:58, Karen clicked a small presentation remote and her title slide appeared on the wall behind her.

 It said community waterfell crisis emergency action required in red font. The word crisis was underlined. At 7 exactly, she started talking. And here’s the thing about Karen. When she is in her element, when she is fully prepared and standing at the front of a room with a whiteboard and laminated photographs and a presentation remote in her hand, she is actually very good at this. She is organized. She is specific.

She does not ramble. She had three main arguments and she delivered them in order and she had evidence for each one. The health and sanitation argument came first. She had dates and locations of reported droppings. She had a printed statement from someone described as a public health reference, but but I could not read it from where I sat.

 Second argument was visual disruption to common areas. She showed the photographs. Third argument was precedent. She said if the ducks were allowed to stay unchallenged, the lake would become a permanent waterfell habitat and the population would grow and the problem would compound annually. That last argument was in purely logical terms not wrong.

 I thought about the 14 ducks on my dock and I did not say anything. She was 12 minutes into the presentation when she moved to the removal plan. She explained the pest control service. She explained what coal meant without using that word. She explained the cost, $1,800 from the community fund.

 She said it was an unfortunate but necessary expense to protect the quality of life of every resident. She clicked to a new slide and she said, “I want to open this up for discussion before we move to the vote.” Nobody said anything for a moment. And then the back door of the community center opened. Now, here’s what I need you to picture.

 The community center has two doors. the main door at the front near the presentation area. The back door opens into the parking lot. The back door has a small window in it and the motion sensor light outside hits it from behind at night. So when someone comes through that door after dark, there is a backlit moment before you can see who it is. I heard the door.

 I turned around. Half the room turned around. Two men walked in. Both of them in full camouflage from the boots to the collar. orange safety patches still on their vests. They were not carrying anything. They walked in quietly and found two empty chairs at the very back of the room. They sat down.

 They did not say a single word. They just looked at Karen. The room went very quiet. Not the quiet of people thinking about what to say next. The quiet of people who have just understood that something significant is happening and are waiting to see what it is. Karen had stopped mid-sentence. She was standing at the front with her presentation remote in one hand and a laminated photograph in the other.

 She was looking at the back of the room and the expression on her face went through the same four stages I had watched at my fence, but slower this time and ending somewhere different. She knew them. Of course, she knew them. She had hired them. She had called them, briefed them, told them what to do and where to go.

And now they were sitting in the back of the community meeting she had called in their full gear in complete silence just looking at her. Nobody said anything. The presentation remote clicked once by accident. The slide changed. Nobody looked at the screen. Karen set the laminated photograph down on the table very slowly, very carefully, like she was making sure not to make any noise.

She put the remote down next to it. She pulled her chair out from behind the table and she sat down. She did not say another word. Nobody mentioned the hunters. Nobody said anything about the camo or the gear or what two men dressed for a duck hunt were doing at an emergency HOA meeting on a Tuesday evening. Nobody looked at Karen.

 Nobody looked at the hunters. Nobody in that entire room of 31 people said one single thing for five full minutes. I have sat through a lot of quiet in my life. Quiet at fishing in the early morning. quiet in houses after people I knew had died. The specific quiet right before weather changes.

 I have experienced a lot of different kinds of silence. That silence in that room on that Tuesday was unlike anything else I have felt before or since. It had weight. Everybody in that room understood something and nobody needed to say it out loud. And so nobody did. 5 minutes. And then Margaret stood up. She did not clear her throat.

 She did not look around for permission. She just stood up from her chair like she had been sitting there waiting for the right moment and had decided this was it. And she said, “Calm as anything, I move. We vote on something else.” There was a sound in that room, not a laugh, something close to a laugh, but not quite.

 The sound of 30 people exhaling at the same time. Someone said seconded. Margaret said, “I would like to put forward a motion to designate all malard ducks currently residing at the community lake as officially protected wildlife under HOA jurisdiction. No removal, no interference, protected status permanent and binding.” There was a silence that lasted about 3 seconds and then someone in the second row said, “I second that.

” Karen said, “That is not a proper motion. That is not even an agenda item.” Margaret looked at her. She said, “I have lived in this neighborhood for 34 years. I have attended every single HOA meeting we have ever had. I know what a proper motion looks like. She sat back down. The vote happened 31 to1. Karen was the only no. Someone wrote it down.

 Someone else said it should go in the minutes. The minutes person, a quiet man named Gerald, who has been recording HOA minutes for 11 years and has the energy of a man who has seen everything, wrote it down without visible emotion. Business as usual. Just another line in the official record of this neighborhood.

 And then there was another long silence. Not quite as long as the first one, but long enough. Margaret stood back up. The room went very still. She said, “I have one more motion.” Nobody said anything. Not one person. No shuffle of chairs, no clearing of throats. You could hear the parking lot light buzzing outside through the wall. Everyone in that room was looking at Margaret except for Karen, who was looking at the table.

 Margaret said, “I move that the HOA president be required to obtain written approval from a majority of homeowners before contacting any external service provider for any matter relating to common area wildlife or community lake issues.” Someone said seconded. Karen said that motion is targeted harassment of a specific officer.

 Margaret said, “Would anyone else like to speak to the motion before we vote?” Nobody spoke. The vote was 31 to1. Gerald wrote it down and then the meeting just sort of ended. Nobody made a formal motion to adjourn. People just started putting on jackets and picking up chairs. Conversations started in the normal way that conversations start when a meeting is over.

 The hunters in the back stood up, nodded at nobody in particular, and walked back out the door. They came in. No one stopped them. No one spoke to them. They just left. I was putting my jacket on when Dave came over from the second row. He leaned in and he said very quietly, “Are those ducks actually your pets?” I looked at him.

 I said, “They sure do follow me around everywhere.” Dave looked at me for a long moment. He had a very specific expression on his face that I recognized as the expression of a man who has decided he does not need to ask any more questions about this particular topic. He nodded slowly. He put his hat on and he said, “Good night.” And he walked out.

 I was one of the last ones to leave. I held the door for Gerald who was packing up his binder. I walked to my car and when I got to the edge of the parking lot, I turned around and looked back at the community center. Karen’s car was still there, just her car, all the lights still on inside. No movement. She was still sitting in there at the front table alone. I drove home.

 I sat on my back porch. The lake was dark and still. I could just make out a few ducks on the dock, white shapes in the low light, already settled in for the night. And I thought about the one motion Margaret said she had that she did not get to finish. She had stood up. She had said, “I have one more motion.

” And then the room had gone completely quiet. And then the vote on the previous motion had ended and people had just started leaving. And Margaret had gathered her things and walked out with everyone else. The motion never happened. I do not know what that motion was. I never asked her. I thought about knocking on her door a few days later and asking, but I did not.

 Some things are better as questions than answers. Whatever she was going to say in that room, I think she decided the situation had resolved itself sufficiently without it. And she was probably right. Margaret has been right about most things for 34 years in this neighborhood. I see no reason to doubt her judgment. Now, that was 9 months ago. The ducks are still there.

There are 29 of them now. The original 14 and 15 new ones from two different nesting seasons. I bought a 50 lb bag of feed 3 months ago. I keep it in a sealed bin just inside the back gate. Every time I drive in through the gate, they somehow know before I have even gotten to the back of the car.

 I do not know if it is the sound of my engine or the way I park or just a frequency I produce that they have learned to recognize, but but they are already off the dock and coming across the water before I have gotten the bin open. 29 of them moving toward me across the surface of that lake all at once in the early morning.

 I will not tell you it is not one of the better things I have seen in recent memory. Karen still drives past that lake every single day. Her commute takes her down the main road that runs along the edge of the property. She has not changed her route. She has not found another way. Every morning she drives past and every morning she does not slow down. And she does not look left.

 I have watched it happen maybe a hundred times now. Same speed, same straight ahead gaze. Like the lake is not there, like the ducks are not there. Like none of it is happening 30 ft to her left. One morning last month, I was out at the W’s edge with the feed bin. The whole group of them was around my feet doing what they do, and I heard a car slow down on the road.

 I looked up and saw Karen’s car moving slower than usual. Not stopped, just slower. I could catch her looking just for a second at the ducks, at me, and at the lake that is 72% mine. Then she sped up. She didn’t stop. She just kept going. I looked back at the ducks. They hadn’t noticed. completely indifferent to the car, to the woman inside it, to the nine months of everything that had happened, between that woman and this lake and me.

 They were just eating, completely present. Not a single one of them thinking about anything except what was directly in front of them. I thought about that for a while. Nobody has ever asked me whether those ducks are actually my pets. Dave came the closest and then decided not to. A few neighbors have made small observations over the months.

How the ducks seem to recognize me, how they respond to my car, how they follow me along the bank. Nobody has connected those observations to the fence line conversation or the hunters or anything else. The story has just settled into the neighborhood as a fact of life. The ducks are there. They like me.

 They are protected by an official HOA vote. That seems to be the entire story as far as anyone around here is concerned. And that is where I have left it. I haven’t offered any clarification. I haven’t told anyone what I said to the hunters or why I said it. I haven’t mentioned it to Karen or to anybody. Some situations resolve themselves cleanest when you don’t add any more words to them.

 Last week, I filled the bin and walked out to the gate. I heard them coming across the water before I even had the lid off. All 29 of them hitting the bank and waddling over in their loose unhurried way. The one with the white patch right at the front. I stood there in the morning quiet and fed my ducks or whatever they are. You decide.

Drop me a comment and tell me what you think. And if this is the kind of story you want more of, you know what to do. If you’ve got your own story, share it down there, too. Because some of you have sent me things that make my situations look completely mild. Hit the like button if you made it this far.

 It helps this channel more than most people realize. And subscribe if you haven’t already because the next story is already coming and I promise you it is worse than this one. Now, one last thing. I put everything into these stories for free and I plan to keep doing that. But if these videos mean something to you, if they make you laugh or frustrated or just feel like you’re not alone in dealing with people like this, consider joining the membership.